Review of Pete 'n' Keely

Bickering between onstage personalities isn’t that uncommon if you look back on television history – think Jerry Lewis and Dean Martin, Sonny and Cher. Their barbs can prove entertaining, especially when the two are a divorced couple who have been quarreling for years and are now getting back together for a one-night performance. That’s the comic set-up for Swift Creek Mill Theatre’s new production of “Pete ‘n’ Keely.”


The musical spins the tale of Pete Bartel and Keely Stevens, two singers who made it to the top of the charts as husband and wife. The two are back together again to tape a television special highlighting their career. The evening is supposed to be nostalgic, but the two keep tossing digs at each other.

Director Tom Width made a wise choice in casting two powerhouse singers – Robyn O’Neill and Russell Rowland – as the quarrelling duo. The show’s television production premise is quite effective. However, the pace in the first act seems a bit disjointed at times. It picks up in the second act where you’ll find more chemistry between the actors and heartier laughs.

The show’s charm lies in O’Neill and Rowland who belt out over 20 songs over the course of the production. As Pete, Rowland gives a solid performance along with spot-on vocals. His hilarious take on the song “Fever” is great fun to watch.

O”Neill is a delight as Keely. She gives a feisty performance that picks up on the anger that Keely has been holding onto for years. As far as her vocals, O’Neill never fails to give a top-notch performance.

Anyone who likes great singing coupled with a comedic premise will enjoy “Pete ‘n’ Keely.” It’s a lighthearted show that entertains.

“Pete ‘n’ Keely” runs through March 13th at Swift Creek Mill Theatre. For Joan Tupponce.com, this is Joan with One Woman’s View.